Movie Mining

Digging beneath the surface of cinema

‘Clayface’ Review: Appalling in all the best ways through one single point of excellence, leaving the rest mostly inconsequential

Clayface (2026)
Courtesy of Warner Bros. Pictures
Director James Watkins
Runtime 1h 48m
Rated R
Genres Horror, Thriller, Sci-Fi
Country United States
Release Year 2026
Starring Tom Rhys Harries, Naomi Ackie, David Dencik
Studio DC Studios, Troll Court Entertainment
Distributor Warner Bros. Pictures

Clayface excited me from its onset because I love body horror, and that looked like exactly what the film was aiming for with its R-rating. On top of that, I had faith in James Gunn and the DCU creative team to execute this project only if they felt it was worthwhile and meaningful. However, the fear still remained that it would turn out like one of the awful films from Sony’s Spider-Man Universe, such as Morbius. Just look at the similarities: each takes a villain from a popular hero’s rogues’ gallery and centers an origin story around that character. The formula has been seen over and over before, where a normal, thriving person gets their life derailed and turns to a volatile scientific treatment that changes who they are. What made Sony’s variations so ineffective was their insistence on still making their villains heroes in their own stories, on top of the fact that the writing and overall film quality were terrible.

The relief with Clayface is that it does not take that turn into anti-hero crap. This is a true, authentic villain origin story, where Matt Hagen undergoes a journey of self-destructive tragedy with a clear character arc, ultimately becoming the primary threat of the story despite being the protagonist—as he should. He is the villain. The story otherwise never explores anything particularly novel—it is a classic revenge tale—and it has faults that weaken some of its impact, but it is great fun regardless. Even with its fantastical premise, the most important aspect of the film is that it stays character-focused and as grounded as possible, never devolving into the standard third-act CGI slop so common in modern comic book films.

Matt Hagen at a red carpet event
Courtesy of Warner Bros. Pictures

Body horror is my favorite subgenre of horror since it allows for such unique creative freedom of expression. There are almost endless directions you can go with it, which means there is always something new to experiment with within the space. In the case of Clayface, there are plenty of gooey paths to take, and the film takes advantage of that potential pretty well, as it is suitably its focus. The character setups happen fairly quickly to get to the real meat of the squirm-inducing sequences inside the revenge plot. The movie goes from serviceable to exceptional when it begins to step on the gas in this department, and the dramatic story overlaid on top of it only serves that momentum. I mentioned the gooey factor, but the film also incorporates the clumpiness, droopiness, and malleable attributes of clay throughout, especially during the kills, which truly mold the experience into quite the disgusting delight at times.

Still, Clayface feels as though it pulls its punches on occasion, and it easily could have gone a step further with its gruesomeness. Don’t get me wrong, there are plenty of grotesque moments present, but it could have aspired to even more. What makes this most confounding to me is that the R-rating was clearly committed to for most of the film, so why the hesitation during these instances? At multiple points, the camera cuts away or leaves some of the violence off-screen, which felt like attempts to restrain itself to a PG-13 rating for whatever reason. This does not happen often, but just enough for me to question the film’s direction in its approach to full-on horror, because it left a little bit to be desired. I wanted more.

Matt Hagen in the hospital wrapped in bandages
Courtesy of Warner Bros. Pictures

Outside of the body horror, Clayface is for the most part just serviceable. The best way I can describe it is tropey, but competently tropey. It is never nearly as bad as something like Morbius, but the plot unfolds almost exactly as expected, and everything it includes has basically been seen before. On one hand, it is a standard revenge story—crossing names off a list one by one. On the other, it is an introspective look into someone who is a victim of what their body is turning into, with increasingly dangerous ramifications as his power grows. I just wish it had introduced new ideas on that front, rather than mixing in familiar beats like an uncomplicated love triangle subplot. But as I said, it is all well-executed enough, even great in some parts, which successfully allows most of the audience’s attention to be placed on that awesome body horror factor.

The biggest issue with Clayface is that in its revenge quest, it ends up pulling the same trick too many times with the morphing ability. This causes much of the plot to become predictable and a bit stale, since it keeps repeating itself. This especially affected the final twist of the film, which was obvious to see coming by that point. The other negative regarding the morphing is how sudden it feels when it happens, especially in the back third of the film. It could have benefited from a more fluid, tactile transition, since it is the only element in the film that does not feel clay-like. Instead, the final product makes the power feel like switching between the undercover face masks seen in the Mission: Impossible franchise. Thankfully, the film makes up for much of this in its payoffs involving all the fun kills, each holding a unique level of satisfaction.

Clayface laying in a bathtub
Courtesy of Warner Bros. Pictures

I am still thoroughly impressed by the overall cohesion of Clayface. It does not exactly reach for the stars, but it covers all its essential bases while excelling in one specific area. There are no blatant plot holes as far as I can tell; the film explains why clothes are part of the morphing process, and there is always a narrative reason behind each mutation escalation.

As for the city of Gotham, I do not really care that it feels like any other city. It actually helps to enhance the feeling of realism in the world and separates it from feeling like a comic book, which may sound sacrilege to some. The truth is, I do not think making the city any grittier would have helped the movie one way or another. I like the natural backdrop as it is. That stance changes a bit when considering the future the DCU is supposed to have, but that is, for the time being, irrelevant to the purposes of this standalone film.

Clayface will be a niche movie by comic book standards, but as a body horror enjoyer, it met my expectations. Unfortunately, it did not surpass them, but I cannot say I was not entertained, especially considering the lackluster October movie slate thus far. The film is significant in that it proves comic book films can get away with branching out and exploring focused genres, keeping things individual and fresh instead of repetitive. Personally, it is better when such properties feel closer to something like The Fly than what Avengers: Doomsday looks to be. And while the script was not spectacular, it was balanced out by a strong creative vision, which is just as impactful when determining a film’s quality and ceiling.

Final Grade B+ The body horror of Clayface is its main draw, which it excels at, so it’s barely an inconvenience that the film’s floor is just passable despite relying on tired tropes.